Compare Execution Types
FXCM has two types of forex execution: No Dealing Desk (NDD) and Dealing Desk. The execution you choose impacts your trading experience and spreads. We recommend NDD execution because we believe it provides our best all-around trading experience. FXCM also offers a Dealing Desk execution option for traders whose primary concern is low spreads for 12 of FXCM's most popular currency pairs. The Dealing Desk offering, however, has certain trading limitations. To determine which execution offering is best for you, please consult the table below.
|
No Dealing Desk (Recommended) |
Dealing Desk 12 Most Popular Pairs |
|
| General | ||
|---|---|---|
| Maximum Balance | None | $25,000 |
| Maximum Trade Size | 50 Million | 50 Million |
| Price Feed | NDD | Dealing Desk |
| Spreads | EUR/USD pips View All |
EUR/USD pips View All |
| Order Execution | ||
| Re-Quote Orders1 | No FXCM does not re-quote orders or manipulate market prices. |
No FXCM does not re-quote orders or manipulate market prices. |
| Conflict of Interest | No FXCM cannot profit from the trading losses of its clients. |
Yes FXCM can profit from the trading losses of its clients on some currency pairs. |
| Anonymous Orders | Yes FXCM’s liquidity providers cannot see your stop, limit and entry orders. |
No FXCM can see your stop, limit and entry orders, but FXCM does not re-quote orders or manipulate prices. |
| Partial Fills | Yes Orders can be broken up and filled at multiple prices (at your discretion). |
Yes Orders can be broken up and filled at multiple prices (at your discretion). |
| Strategies | ||
| Scalping | Yes Scalp the market with no restrictions. |
Yes Scalping is allowed, but FXCM reserves the right to manage its risk by changing your execution type. |
| News Trading | Yes Trade news events with no restrictions. |
Yes News trading is allowed, but FXCM reserves the right to manage its risk by changing your execution type. |
| Automation (e.g. EAs) | Yes Automate your trading with no restrictions. Use any EA. |
Yes Automated trading is allowed, but FXCM reserves the right to manage its risk by changing your execution type. |
| API Trading | Yes Trade with APIs and no restrictions. |
Yes Trade with APIs, but FXCM reserves the right to manage its risk by changing your execution type to NDD. |
The No Dealing Desk (NDD) price feed comes from many liquidity providers who compete with one another for FXCM order flow. These liquidity providers include global banks, financial institutions, and other market makers. At any given time, the NDD price feed automatically streams the best bid and best ask prices to FXCM platforms. This efficient selection method inhibits a single liquidity provider from adversely affecting FXCM's NDD price feed. The more advantageous their prices are, the more order flow the liquidity provider receives. The less advantageous their prices are, the less order flow they receive. We believe FXCM's NDD prices are the most competitive, market-driven, and fair.
Dealing Desk execution is used by many brokers in the forex industry. However, FXCM's Dealing Desk execution offering is unique because it shares important features with our No Dealing Desk (NDD) execution. FXCM's dealing desk execution option is able to offer spreads for FXCM's 12 most popular currency pairs that may be up to one pip lower than those provided by the No Dealing Desk (NDD) model. While FXCM believes that NDD execution provides the best all-around trading experience, we also offer dealing desk execution as an option for traders whose primary concern is low spreads on FXCM's 12 most popular currency pairs.
On FXCM's 12 most popular currency pairs, the Dealing Desk execution offers competitive spreads that may be up to one pip lower than FXCM's No Dealing Desk (NDD) spreads. FXCM does not, however, guarantee that quotes, prices or spreads will always be better on one form of execution as compared to the other. Please note that for all other pairs, spreads, quotes, or prices may, at times, be less competitive on Dealing Desk execution.
| No Dealing Desk | Dealing Desk | |
|---|---|---|
| EUR/USD | pips | pips |
| AUD/USD | pips | pips |
| GBP/USD | pips | pips |
| GBP/JPY | pips | pips |
| NZD/USD | pips | pips |
| USD/JPY | pips | pips |
| USD/CHF | pips | pips |
| EUR/CHF | pips | pips |
| USD/CAD | pips | pips |
| EUR/GBP | pips | pips |
| EUR/JPY | pips | pips |
| AUD/JPY | pips | pips |
Advertised Spreads
FXCM spreads are variable. The spreads listed here were derived from the time-weighted average of the spreads from to . Advertised spreads may not be applicable to client accounts of referring brokers.
Compensation
When executing customers trades, FXCM can be compensated in several ways, which include, but are not limited to: adding a mark-up to the spreads it receives from its liquidity providers, receiving compensation for order flow, and charging commission to accounts that trade with FXCM's lowest spreads which are available to qualifying accounts. Under the Dealing Desk execution model, FXCM may act as a dealer and may receive additional compensation from trading.
Some trading strategies like scalping can cause problems for dealing desks. They reduce the amount of time that a dealing desk has to hedge its trading risk. When this happens, a dealing desk will often begin re-quoting orders, which gives them more time to manage their trades and changes the market price to one that is more advantageous for their positions. But clearly, this is not beneficial for you.
FXCM's dealing desk is different. We do not re-quote orders or manipulate market prices. If your trading style exposes us to more risk than we care to manage, we will simply change your forex execution type to No Dealing Desk.
Some strategies that trade the news can cause problems for dealing desks. They reduce the amount of time that a dealing desk has to hedge its trading risk. When this happens, a dealing desk will often begin re-quoting orders, which gives them more time to manage their trades and changes the market price to one that is more advantageous for their positions. But clearly, this is not beneficial for you.
FXCM's dealing desk is different. We do not re-quote orders or manipulate market prices. If your trading style exposes us to more risk than we care to manage, we will simply change your forex execution type to No Dealing Desk.
Some automated trading strategies, especially those that trade at a high frequency or scalp the market, can cause problems for dealing desks. They reduce the amount of time that a dealing desk has to hedge its trading risk. When this happens, a dealing desk will often begin re-quoting orders, which gives them more time to manage their trades and changes the market price to one that is more advantageous for their positions. But clearly, this is not beneficial for you.
FXCM's dealing desk is different. We do not re-quote orders or manipulate market prices. If your trading style exposes us to more risk than we care to manage, we will simply change your forex execution type to No Dealing Desk.
1 No Re-Quote Policy: FXCM maintains a no re-quote policy. Circumstances exist based on order size, trading pattern, and market conditions where individuals may not receive execution at the requested rate. Orders are executed at the next available rate within the trader's parameters, subject to market conditions. The difference between the requested rate and final execution price may be more or less advantageous based on the market activity and available liquidity.
Dealing Desk: On the Dealing Desk execution model FXCM can act as the dealer on some currency pairs. There are also back up liquidity providers that fill in whenever FXCM does not act as the dealer. Please note that FXCM's Dealing Desk employs fewer liquidity providers than the No Dealing Desk (NDD) execution option. FXCM does not guarantee that quotes, prices, or spreads will always be better on one form of execution as compared to the other. Customers should consider many factors when deciding which execution type best suits their needs (e.g., conflict of interest, trading style or strategy, etc.). For more information, see our Execution Risks.